Syed Ali Nadeem Rezavi

This is the second in a short series on cinematic historical storytelling. In the first we discussed some Indian films dealing with historical themes and how they tried to tailor the past for us. Here we are going to look at two Turkish mega serials which were watched at the international level and can be seen in Turkish, English, and Urdu dubbings. One of them was made widely available on Amazon.
The Turkish historical television serials Diriliş: Ertuğrul and Kuruluş: Osman stand among the most impressive historical dramas produced in recent decades. Their appeal extends far beyond Turkey, attracting audiences across the Middle East, South Asia, Central Asia and Europe. With spectacular battle sequences, carefully designed costumes, impressive sets, memorable characters and emotionally engaging narratives, they have brought a relatively unfamiliar period of medieval history into the homes of millions. Yet their significance lies not merely in entertainment. They offer an opportunity to explore the origins of the Ottoman state, the social and material culture of the medieval Turkic world, the relationship between Islam and political authority, and the ways in which the past is reconstructed to serve the concerns of the present.
The two productions are closely connected, but their historical settings and central concerns differ. Ertuğrul, first broadcast in 2014, revolves around the struggles of Ertuğrul Bey, portrayed by Engin Altan Düzyatan, as he attempts to secure the survival and future of his Kayı tribe amidst the political upheavals of thirteenth-century Anatolia. Osman, which followed in 2019, presents his son, played by Burak Özçivit, as the architect of a new political order that would eventually develop into the Ottoman Empire. The first is essentially a story of tribal survival, kinship, loyalty and the search for a homeland. The second concerns the transition from tribal leadership to territorial sovereignty and the beginnings of dynastic state formation.
As historical reconstructions, however, both must be approached with caution. The early history of the Ottoman dynasty remains surrounded by considerable uncertainty. Although Ertuğrul is generally accepted as the father of Osman, reliable contemporary information concerning his life is extremely limited, and even his genealogy is disputed. While the serial identifies Süleyman Şah as his father, other traditions name Gündüz Alp, an identification that many historians consider more credible. The elaborate conspiracies, encounters with Crusaders, Mongols and Byzantine commanders, and the personal relationships that occupy much of the narrative are largely products of the scriptwriters’ imagination.
The historical foundation of Osman is somewhat firmer. The Byzantine historian George Pachymeres refers to a Turkish leader generally identified as Osman in connection with the Battle of Bapheus in 1302, providing valuable contemporary evidence of his growing military importance. The emergence of the Ottoman principality along the Byzantine frontier is also a recognisable historical process. Nevertheless, much of the detailed narrative presented in the serial derives from later Ottoman traditions or dramatic invention. The famous dream of Osman, in which a tree grows from his body and spreads across the world, belongs to the dynastic legends through which the Ottomans subsequently explained and legitimised their rise. The political achievements of Osman were real, but the notion that he consciously pursued a fully developed imperial mission is a retrospective interpretation.
The early Ottoman principality was merely one amongst several Turkish political formations that emerged as Seljuk authority weakened under Mongol pressure. Its eventual expansion was not inevitable. Geography, military organisation, control over resources, relationships with neighbouring Byzantine communities, political alliances and the incorporation of diverse populations all contributed to its development. The work of historians such as Halil İnalcık, Cemal Kafadar and Colin Imber has demonstrated the difficulties involved in separating the historical circumstances of Ottoman origins from the legends subsequently constructed around them.
Yet to dismiss Ertuğrul as historically worthless because much of its narrative is fictional would be equally mistaken. One of its most valuable achievements is the vivid reconstruction of the social, cultural and material environment of the medieval Turkic pastoral world. The serial allows viewers to enter a society whose institutions and everyday practices are not easily visualised through conventional political histories. Its portrayal of tribal encampments, domestic arrangements, communal gatherings, political assemblies, productive activities and customary obligations offers a fascinating introduction to a way of life rooted in the traditions of the Central Asian steppes.
The tribal encampment, or oba, occupies a central place in this reconstruction. Its circular tents, arranged around open spaces used for communal activities, create a distinctive physical and social environment. These portable dwellings, commonly associated with the wider Central Asian tradition of the yurt, were designed to accommodate the requirements of pastoral mobility. Their wooden frameworks, felt coverings and carefully arranged interiors provided protection from climatic extremes while allowing relatively rapid dismantling and transportation. The more elaborate tents of the tribal leadership, often referred to as otağ, functioned not merely as residences but as spaces for receiving visitors, conducting political deliberations and exercising authority.
The interiors are amongst the most attractive features of the production. Carpets, kilims, embroidered hangings, cushions, wooden chests, leather containers, metal vessels, low tables and weapons create an atmosphere of considerable material richness. The central hearth provides warmth and becomes a gathering place for family members, while the arrangement of furnishings reflects distinctions of status, age and authority. The tent of the bey is particularly impressive, its larger dimensions and elaborate decoration indicating the prestige of the ruling household.
Such representations remind us that pastoral mobility did not imply cultural backwardness or material poverty. Turkic communities possessed sophisticated traditions of weaving, felt-making, leatherworking, metalworking and woodworking. Carpets and textiles were not simply ornamental possessions. They provided insulation, furnished domestic spaces, expressed social identity and constituted valuable commodities. The production of portable furnishings was closely connected with the requirements of a society in which households might move seasonally between grazing grounds.
The pastoral economy itself emerges through the prominence of horses, sheep, goats and other livestock. Horses were essential for transport, warfare and prestige, while sheep and goats provided meat, milk, wool and hides. The movement between summer and winter pastures, known in Turkic traditions as yaylak and kışlak, formed an important element of economic organisation. Control over grazing lands, water sources and migration routes was therefore closely connected with political authority. Disputes over territory were not always expressions of abstract ambitions for conquest; they could arise from the practical requirements of maintaining the livelihood of a mobile community.
The serial also draws attention to the economic importance of women’s labour. Women are frequently shown weaving carpets, preparing food, producing clothing, managing stores and organising the domestic economy. These activities sustained the tribe and contributed to the production of goods that could be exchanged in neighbouring markets. The encampment was consequently not merely a residential settlement or military base. It was also a centre of production, consumption and social reproduction.
One must nevertheless remember that the circular, domed yurts so prominently displayed in Ertuğrul were not necessarily the universal dwellings of all Oghuz communities in thirteenth-century Anatolia. Turkic pastoral groups employed different kinds of portable shelters, including felt-covered structures and tents made from woven animal hair. Some of the richly furnished interiors may reflect later Ottoman or modern reconstructions of Turkish cultural traditions. The serial presents a visually coherent interpretation of medieval pastoral life rather than an archaeologically exact reproduction of a particular Kayı encampment.
The political organisation of this society is equally interesting. The tribal chief, or bey, exercises considerable authority, but his position depends upon the loyalty of warriors, the support of influential families and his ability to protect the community. Councils and assemblies provide occasions for discussing migration, warfare, alliances, succession and internal disputes. The toy, or communal assembly, represents an important element of the wider Turkic political tradition, although the precise procedures depicted in the serial should not be assumed to reproduce those of the thirteenth century.
Leadership in such a society was personal, but it was not necessarily arbitrary. A chief was expected to demonstrate courage, generosity, wisdom and respect for established customs. The distribution of resources, the maintenance of military companionship and the fulfilment of reciprocal obligations helped sustain his authority. Customary norms, often associated with the Turkic concept of töre, regulated aspects of political legitimacy and social conduct. With the spread of Islam, these inherited traditions interacted with Islamic legal and ethical ideas, producing political cultures in which customary practice and religious norms existed alongside one another.
The significance of kinship is repeatedly emphasised. The authority of elders, obligations towards relatives, the honour attached to hospitality and the importance of loyalty amongst companions form the moral foundations of tribal life. Communal meals, marriages, mourning ceremonies and celebrations become occasions for reaffirming collective identity. At the same time, the serial makes clear that tribal society was not entirely egalitarian. Wealth, lineage, control over livestock, possession of horses and weapons, and proximity to the ruling household created distinctions of rank and influence.
For historians of medieval India, these representations possess a particular attraction. The Turkish military and ruling elites who established the Delhi Sultanate emerged from the broader Central Asian Turkic world, although they did not necessarily belong to the same Oghuz tribal traditions as the Kayı. When one reads Minhaj-i Siraj’s Tabaqat-i Nasiri, Barani’s Tarikh-i Firuz Shahi and other early Persian chronicles, one encounters comparable ideas concerning personal allegiance, military companionship, lineage, the authority of senior members of ruling households and the obligations binding leaders to their followers.
The Turkish ruling groups associated with Iltutmish and the Shamsi nobles operated within a much more developed Persianate political and administrative environment than the tribal society depicted in Ertuğrul. Nevertheless, beneath these differences one can recognise elements of a shared Central Asian political inheritance. The importance of personal loyalty, the prestige attached to military service, the role of influential households and the distribution of honours were not peculiar to Anatolia. They belonged to a wider political culture that had developed through the interaction of Turkic traditions, Persianate institutions and Islamic ideas.
The comparison must not be pushed too far. The Turkish elites of Delhi included people of diverse Central Asian backgrounds, and their institutions had been profoundly transformed through service under earlier Islamic dynasties. Nor can the ceremonies and customs depicted in a modern television serial be treated as direct evidence for medieval practice. Nevertheless, Ertuğrul offers a useful visual framework for understanding aspects of the social environment from which several Turkic ruling traditions emerged.
Speaking personally, I have watched Ertuğrul more than once and have found it genuinely rewarding. In spite of its many factual errors, which are considerable, I would recommend it to anyone seeking to understand the Turkish phase of the Delhi Sultanate, particularly the period of the Ilbari Turks in northern India. The world of the Ilbaris, the dynasty to which Iltutmish belonged, was rooted in precisely the kind of Central Asian tribal society that Ertuğrul brings to life on screen. The notions of personal loyalty, tribal solidarity, the authority of elders, the prestige of military service, the circulation of horses and weapons, the importance of marriage alliances and the constant negotiation between customary law and Islamic norms that one encounters in the chronicles of the Delhi Sultanate are all rendered visible in the serial. A student of Minhaj-i Siraj or Barani can benefit from watching Ertuğrul precisely because it provides an imaginative entry into a social world that the Persian chronicles presuppose rather than describe. The Ilbari Turks of northern India, like the Kayı of the serial, were pastoralists and warriors whose political authority rested upon kinship, personal allegiance and the successful management of tribal coalitions. The visual reconstruction of the oba, the toy and the töre in Ertuğrul therefore offers a valuable, if imperfect, window into the mental and material universe from which the Delhi Sultanate emerged. One must read the serial critically and check its details against the sources, but as an aid to the historical imagination, it is difficult to match.
The series is particularly effective in portraying the relationship between the household and political authority. The tent of the bey is simultaneously a domestic residence, council chamber and centre of government. Decisions concerning warfare, migration, marriage and succession are intertwined with family relationships. This is a world in which the distinction between private and public authority is far less sharply defined than in a developed bureaucratic state. The gradual transformation of such leadership into territorial sovereignty provides the historical bridge between Ertuğrul and Osman.
The latter serial depicts a society increasingly concerned with the conquest and administration of fortified settlements, the organisation of military forces and the establishment of more permanent political institutions. Yet the transition was not simply from nomadism to settled civilisation. The early Ottoman polity emerged through interaction between pastoral groups, agricultural communities, towns, markets and existing Byzantine institutions. The pastoral and settled worlds were economically interconnected, and the boundaries between them were often fluid. The serials occasionally acknowledge these relationships, but their emphasis upon heroic leadership tends to obscure the collective and economic dimensions of state formation.
Another important dimension of both productions is their representation of Islam. In Ertuğrul, religion is not portrayed merely as a collection of prescribed rituals or as a justification for military conquest. It is presented as an ethical and spiritual framework in which justice, compassion, hospitality, humility and the protection of the weak occupy central positions. The recurring presence of Ibn al-Arabi, the celebrated Andalusian mystic, gives this interpretation particular significance. He appears as a spiritual guide whose teachings help Ertuğrul negotiate the moral dilemmas of political leadership.
Historically, Ibn al-Arabi travelled through Anatolia and died in Damascus in 1240, but there is no reliable evidence establishing the personal relationship with Ertuğrul depicted in the serial. His inclusion is therefore an imaginative device, intended to associate the Ottoman beginnings with the mystical and philosophical traditions of Islam. Nevertheless, it introduces viewers to a religious outlook in which spiritual understanding and moral responsibility are placed alongside outward observance.
This interpretation has considerable relevance to the history of medieval Anatolia. The region was a meeting ground of different religious, linguistic and cultural communities. The traditions associated with Jalaluddin Rumi, Hacı Bektaş Veli and other mystics developed within an environment shaped by encounters between Turks, Persians, Greeks, Armenians and other populations. Sufi networks, wandering dervishes and religious fraternities contributed to the circulation of ideas across political and communal boundaries. The Islam that emerged within this environment was not uniform, and its history cannot be reduced either to tolerance or to religious conflict.
The serials draw selectively upon this inheritance. They repeatedly emphasise that honourable conduct, compassion and justice are not necessarily confined to members of one’s own religious community. Individuals belonging to other faiths may receive protection, hospitality and respect, while conversion to Islam is sometimes represented as the outcome of personal conviction rather than compulsion. This inclusive vision is amongst the more appealing aspects of Ertuğrul, particularly at a time when Islam is frequently represented in popular entertainment through images of extremism and intolerance.
Yet there is a striking contradiction between this expansive spiritual message and the manner in which the serial portrays its political adversaries. While the Turkish protagonists are generally shown as courageous, honourable, generous and committed to justice, Christians, particularly the Templar knights and certain religious figures, are frequently represented as scheming, treacherous and morally corrupt. Mongol commanders are often depicted as savage, bloodthirsty and almost entirely devoid of humane qualities. The result is a narrative in which moral virtue becomes closely associated with Turkish Muslim identity, while cruelty and deception are repeatedly assigned to outsiders.
Such characterisation is historically misleading. The Mongol conquests undoubtedly involved enormous destruction, massacres and the devastation of important cities. Yet Mongol history cannot be reduced to barbarism. The Mongols developed sophisticated systems of military organisation, communication, administration and imperial governance. Their empire facilitated commercial exchanges and the movement of merchants, scholars, craftsmen and religious communities across vast territories. Mongol rulers and elites followed different religious traditions, including Buddhism, Christianity and Islam, and their policies towards religious communities varied considerably.
The history of the Delhi Sultanate provides a useful comparison. The Turkish rulers of Delhi confronted repeated Mongol incursions, and the Persian chroniclers understandably regarded them as formidable enemies. Yet the same period also witnessed the settlement of Mongol groups in northern India, some of whom converted to Islam and entered the service of the Sultans. The New Muslims associated with the reign of Jalaluddin Khalji remind us that conflict and accommodation could coexist. The Mongols were not an undifferentiated mass of savage invaders, just as the Turks were not invariably embodiments of justice and tolerance.
The depiction of Christians is equally problematic. Medieval Anatolia contained substantial Greek and Armenian Christian populations whose relationships with Turkish rulers were shaped by warfare, diplomacy, commerce, cooperation and everyday social interaction. Christian merchants, artisans, peasants and religious institutions formed part of the society within which the early Ottoman principality developed. Christian warriors could enter Turkish service, political alliances crossed religious boundaries, and conversion was only one amongst several forms of accommodation. The frontier was not simply a battlefield separating two permanently hostile civilisations. It was also a zone of cultural exchange and social mobility.
The weakness of Ertuğrul lies in its reluctance to allow these complexities to shape the personalities of its characters. There are certainly treacherous Turks and occasional honourable individuals amongst rival communities, but such exceptions rarely disturb the fundamental division between virtuous protagonists and wicked adversaries. The Turkish heroes may commit errors, but their actions are generally explained through circumstances that preserve their moral superiority. Comparable understanding is seldom extended to their opponents. There are remarkably few shades of grey.
This absence of moral ambiguity diminishes the historical sophistication of an otherwise impressive production. Medieval societies were no more divided into communities of the virtuous and the wicked than modern societies are. Cruelty, generosity, political ambition, religious conviction and personal integrity could be found amongst Turks, Mongols, Byzantines and Crusaders alike. A more nuanced portrayal would not have weakened the dramatic appeal of the serial. On the contrary, it might have produced more convincing characters and a richer understanding of the world in which they lived.
The contradiction becomes particularly apparent when the spiritual universalism associated with Ibn al-Arabi is placed alongside the political narrative. The mystic’s teachings emphasise humility, compassion and the recognition of human dignity beyond narrow distinctions. Yet the drama repeatedly associates moral superiority with one community and portrays its adversaries through largely negative stereotypes. The universalism of the religious message is consequently constrained by the particularism of the political narrative.
Osman continues the emphasis upon Islamic spirituality, although the relationship between religion and political authority becomes more explicit. Sheikh Edebali, remembered in later Ottoman tradition as Osman’s spiritual guide and father-in-law, occupies a prominent position. The celebrated dream in which a great tree grows from Osman and spreads across the world symbolises the future greatness of the dynasty. Its historical authenticity is doubtful, but its importance as a foundation legend is considerable. It transforms political expansion into the fulfilment of a providential mission and provides spiritual legitimacy to dynastic sovereignty.
The treatment of women constitutes another significant feature of both productions. Unlike many conventional historical dramas in which women are confined to the domestic sphere, Ertuğrul presents them as active participants in the economic, social and political affairs of the tribe. Hayme Ana occupies a position of considerable authority. She advises leaders, intervenes in disputes, influences political decisions and commands the respect of warriors and elders. Her authority rests not merely upon her position as Ertuğrul’s mother but upon her experience, judgement and capacity to maintain tribal solidarity.
Halime Sultan, Selcan Hatun and other female characters similarly display courage, resourcefulness and political awareness. Their participation in domestic production is no less important than their occasional involvement in political affairs. The weaving of carpets, preparation of provisions, management of stores and supervision of household activities remind viewers that the survival of a pastoral community depended upon women’s labour as much as upon the military achievements of its warriors.
In Osman, the female characters become even more visibly associated with political leadership and warfare. Bala Hatun and Malhun Hatun are portrayed as women capable of strategic judgement, armed resistance and participation in the affairs of the emerging state. Their activities reflect the changing circumstances of a society moving from tribal organisation towards territorial sovereignty. Yet the historical evidence concerning the individual women represented in both serials is often limited, and many of their personal relationships and exploits are fictionalised.
The portrayal nevertheless possesses a broader historical foundation. Women in Turkic pastoral societies could enjoy considerable mobility and exercise influence through kinship, control over resources and participation in productive activities. Elite women sometimes played important political roles. Their position cannot be understood simply through assumptions derived from later sedentary or courtly societies.
At the same time, the serials do not present a society free from patriarchal authority. Female courage and independence are generally celebrated when they reinforce family solidarity, tribal honour, religious commitment and the political ambitions of husbands or sons. Women may advise, organise and fight, but they rarely challenge the underlying structure of male political dominance. The result is an interesting combination of female agency and conservative family ideals. Ertuğrul generally integrates women’s activities more naturally into the everyday life of the community, while Osman increasingly places its principal female characters within the larger narrative of conquest and state formation.
The contemporary political significance of these productions is impossible to ignore. Under President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan and the Justice and Development Party, the Ottoman past has acquired renewed prominence in Turkey’s public culture, political rhetoric and representations of national identity. The republican tradition established under Mustafa Kemal Atatürk had emphasised secular nationalism and a conscious reorientation away from aspects of the Ottoman imperial inheritance. Erdoğan’s political discourse, by contrast, has sought to recover that inheritance as a source of national pride, Islamic cultural identity and international prestige.
This phenomenon is often described as neo-Ottomanism, although the term should not be understood as implying a literal programme to recreate the Ottoman Empire. It refers more broadly to the mobilisation of Ottoman historical memory in contemporary political and cultural life. M. Hakan Yavuz has examined how Ottoman nostalgia and Islamic identity reinforce one another within Erdoğan’s political outlook, while studies of Turkish television have identified the role of historical dramas in circulating these narratives.
Ertuğrul fits particularly well into this environment. Produced for Turkey’s public broadcaster TRT, it received visible encouragement from the political leadership. Erdoğan visited its sets, while music and imagery associated with the production appeared at official events. Scholars such as Josh Carney have examined how the serial has been used beyond the television screen to reinforce political narratives concerning national survival, strong leadership and historical continuity.
The parallels between the fictional hero and the political language of contemporary Turkey are striking. Ertuğrul repeatedly confronts powerful external enemies and treacherous elements within his own community. His authority derives from the conviction that he possesses the courage, moral clarity and determination necessary to protect his people. Opposition to his leadership is frequently associated with selfish ambition, betrayal or foreign manipulation. National survival becomes inseparable from loyalty to a strong and supposedly indispensable leader.
Such a narrative can readily acquire contemporary political meanings. Erdoğan has frequently presented Turkey as a country required to defend its sovereignty against external pressures and internal threats. Within this framework, the heroic frontier leader becomes an attractive historical parallel for the modern statesman claiming to protect national independence and collective identity. Recent scholarship has examined how state-supported historical television reproduces elements of contemporary political discourse through narratives situated in the Ottoman past.
This does not mean that every aspect of Ertuğrul was designed as propaganda, or that its viewers necessarily accept the political messages associated with it. Its dramatic qualities, engaging characters and moral themes possess an appeal independent of party politics. Nevertheless, its political appropriation is evident. Historical fiction becomes particularly useful to those exercising power when ideological assumptions are communicated through emotionally compelling narratives rather than explicit political argument.
The international popularity of the serial adds another dimension. In Pakistan, where its Urdu-dubbed version attracted an enormous audience and received encouragement from the country’s political leadership, Ertuğrul helped project a favourable image of Turkey as the inheritor of an illustrious Islamic past. Turkish historical television has consequently become an important instrument of cultural diplomacy, reaching audiences far beyond the country’s geographical boundaries.
For Erdoğan, such popularity offers the possibility of associating contemporary Turkish leadership with the prestige of Ottoman history and the moral authority of Islamic civilisation. It may reinforce his aspiration to be recognised as an influential voice in the wider Muslim world. Yet cultural popularity should not be confused with universal political acceptance. The Muslim world is politically diverse, and Turkey’s claims to regional or religious leadership have encountered both support and opposition. The political effectiveness of historical television is therefore considerable but not unlimited.
The relationship between Ertuğrul and Osman is especially suggestive in this context. The first presents a narrative of collective survival, moral regeneration and the recovery of dignity through faith and unity. The second moves towards the establishment of political sovereignty and territorial expansion. Together, they create an attractive historical sequence in which a community first rediscovers its identity and then transforms that identity into state power. Such a narrative resonates with contemporary political claims concerning Turkey’s national revival and its ambition to exercise greater influence beyond its borders.
This transformation is also reflected in the memorable expressions that have become part of the popular appeal of the two serials. The frequently heard Eyvallah! conveys agreement, acceptance, gratitude or respectful acknowledgement, depending upon the context. It is one of those expressions that have travelled beyond the Turkish language and entered the everyday vocabulary of enthusiastic viewers.
More revealing are the heroic declarations associated with the protagonists. The phrase Ya şehadet ya hürriyet! (Either martyrdom or freedom!) captures the determination to resist subjugation, while Ya şehadet ya muzafferiyet! (Either martyrdom or victory!), associated with the martial spirit of Kuruluş: Osman, places the emphasis upon triumph through sacrifice. Equally significant are the ideals of Hürriyet, Adalet ve Cesaret (Freedom, Justice and Courage), which provide an appropriate summary of the moral universe constructed around Ertuğrul.
These expressions are not merely dramatic slogans. They reveal the different political worlds represented by the two productions. For Ertuğrul, freedom signifies the preservation of tribal autonomy, justice the obligation to protect the weak and uphold moral principles, and courage the willingness to confront oppression despite overwhelming odds. The survival of the community remains the central objective. In Osman, however, the emphasis increasingly shifts towards victory, territorial expansion and the establishment of sovereignty. The movement from hürriyet to muzafferiyet, from freedom to victory, thus symbolises the transition from a community struggling to preserve its independence to a political leadership seeking to create and expand a state.
The language of martyrdom provides the connecting thread. Sacrifice is presented as the highest expression of loyalty to faith and community, whether the immediate objective is freedom or conquest. Yet the political meanings of such sacrifice change with circumstances. The willingness to die defending one’s community is not necessarily identical to the willingness to die extending the authority of a ruler. By presenting both within the same moral vocabulary, the serials blur a distinction that deserves closer historical examination.
There is also a contemporary resonance to these expressions. Freedom, justice, courage, martyrdom and victory are powerful ideals that can be readily incorporated into modern nationalist and religious discourse. Their emotional force allows historical fiction to communicate political meanings without necessarily making explicit political arguments. The popularity of these phrases amongst international audiences demonstrates how effectively the language of historical drama can shape collective perceptions of courage, leadership and identity.
Yet there remains an important tension between the inclusive Islam celebrated in the serials and the nationalist uses to which their imagery may be put. The spiritual teachings associated with Ibn al-Arabi emphasise humility, compassion and the transcendence of narrow worldly ambitions. Political nationalism, on the other hand, often depends upon drawing sharper distinctions between insiders and outsiders, loyalty and betrayal, friends and enemies. The serials attempt to reconcile these tendencies by presenting Turkish political ascendancy as the instrument through which universal Islamic justice is realised. Whether this reconciliation is historically convincing is another matter.
As television productions, both serials possess considerable artistic strengths. Their elaborate sets, costumes, outdoor locations, musical compositions and carefully choreographed combat sequences create an immersive historical atmosphere. Engin Altan Düzyatan brings a restrained dignity to Ertuğrul, combining physical courage with emotional vulnerability and moral introspection. His relationships with Turgut Alp, Bamsı Beyrek, Doğan Alp and members of his family provide warmth, humour and emotional depth. Burak Özçivit portrays Osman as a more assertive and ambitious personality, reflecting the different political circumstances of a leader concerned with establishing territorial authority.
Nevertheless, the productions differ in their dramatic balance. Ertuğrul is generally more successful in integrating personal relationships, tribal politics and moral dilemmas into a coherent narrative. Osman offers a larger political and military canvas but increasingly relies upon spectacular confrontations, repeated conspiracies and the exceptional abilities of its protagonist. Both suffer from excessive length, repetitive dialogue and the recurring pattern of betrayal, confrontation and eventual triumph.
Their treatment of warfare also deserves criticism. Battles are frequently represented as contests between morally defined adversaries, with comparatively little attention to their consequences for ordinary populations. The experiences of cultivators, artisans, traders and inhabitants of conquered settlements remain largely outside the narrative. For the social historian, this is a serious omission. The formation of the Ottoman state involved transformations in agrarian relations, taxation, settlement, commerce and the organisation of labour. Military victories alone cannot explain its emergence.
Indeed, the most historically rewarding moments of Ertuğrul are often not its battles but its quieter scenes of everyday life. The circular tents, their richly furnished interiors, communal meals, tribal councils, domestic production, ceremonies of hospitality and relationships between elders and younger members of the community offer glimpses into the social foundations of political authority. They allow viewers to imagine the world from which the early Ottoman polity emerged, even though the details require critical verification.
Ultimately, Diriliş: Ertuğrul and Kuruluş: Osman deserve appreciation as remarkable achievements of popular historical storytelling. They have introduced millions of viewers to medieval Anatolia, stimulated interest in Ottoman history and demonstrated the capacity of television to bring unfamiliar historical worlds vividly to life. Their portrayal of pastoral society, Turkic cultural traditions, Islamic mysticism and the participation of women gives them an appeal extending beyond conventional narratives of military heroism.
Of the two, Ertuğrul remains the more satisfying dramatic achievement. Its emotional depth, memorable characters and reconstruction of tribal life provide a richness that is not always sustained in Osman. The latter, however, offers a broader historical canvas by attempting to portray the transition from a mobile tribal society to a territorial state. Viewed together, the two productions illuminate, however imperfectly, the social and political transformation that preceded the emergence of one of the world’s most enduring empires.
Their limitations are equally instructive. The glorification of Turkish heroes, the negative stereotyping of Christians and Mongols, the absence of moral ambiguity and the projection of later Ottoman imperial ideals backwards into the thirteenth century remind us that these are contemporary reconstructions rather than faithful reproductions of history. Their political appropriation in modern Turkey further demonstrates how the past can be mobilised to legitimise present-day aspirations.
The historian need not reject such productions because they depart from documented history. Historical fiction necessarily requires imagination, and no television serial can reproduce the past in its entirety. The real difficulty arises when artistic reconstruction is mistaken for historical truth, or when the complexities of the past are reduced to reassuring narratives of collective greatness.
The enduring achievement of Ertuğrul and Osman is that they make medieval history exciting, accessible and emotionally engaging. Their weakness is that they often make it appear more certain, more morally uncomplicated and more purposeful than it actually was. The world they recreate is not simply the world of thirteenth-century Anatolia. It is also a world shaped by the cultural aspirations, political concerns and ideological preferences of twenty-first-century Turkey. Appreciating their artistic brilliance while recognising their historical selectivity allows us to enjoy these productions without surrendering the critical judgement upon which the study of history ultimately depends.





